Modified Comparative Fault System in Indiana

Q: What Is the Modified Comparative Fault System in Indiana?

Getting hurt in a car accident is stressful enough, but learning that you may have played some role in causing it is distressing. Many people assume that sharing any blame means walking away with nothing, yet Indiana law takes a more balanced approach.

Getting hurt in a car accident is stressful enough, but learning that you may have played some role in causing it is distressing. Many people assume that sharing any blame means walking away with nothing, yet Indiana law takes a more balanced approach. The state follows a modified comparative fault system, which allows injured people to recover compensation even when they bear some responsibility, as long as their share of fault stays within a specific legal limit.

How Does the Modified Comparative Fault System Work?

Indiana follows a “modified comparative fault” system, which means an injured person can recover damages as long as they are not more than 50% at fault for the accident. If a court finds that a person bears 51% or more of the fault, that person cannot recover any compensation, while those below that threshold see their award reduced in proportion to their share of fault.

How Does Fault Get Divided Between the Parties?

“Fault” is divided based on evidence presented in the case, which may include police reports, witness statements, photos, and other documentation. A judge or jury reviews all available information and assigns a percentage of fault to each party involved. Because this determination directly affects compensation, the facts of each case carry significant weight.

What Happens if Someone Is Found 20% at Fault?

If a person is found 20% at fault and the total damages amount to $100,000, that person would receive $80,000, because the award is reduced by the fault percentage. This proportional reduction applies regardless of the type of accident involved.

What Is the 51% Bar Rule?

The “51% Bar Rule” is the cutoff point in Indiana’s modified comparative fault system, where any party found 51% or more responsible for an accident loses the right to collect damages entirely. This differs from pure comparative fault states, which allow recovery regardless of how high a person’s fault percentage is. Indiana’s approach places a firm limit on who qualifies.

What Types of Damages Can Be Recovered?

An injured claimant in Indiana may recover “economic” damages such as medical bills, lost wages, and property damage, as well as “non-economic” damages like pain and suffering. The total amount depends on the degree of fault assigned to each party.

Does Indiana’s System Apply to All Personal Injury Cases?

Indiana’s modified comparative fault rules apply broadly to most personal injury cases, including car accidents, truck accidents, slip and fall incidents, and other negligence-based claims. Some exceptions exist, particularly in cases involving product liability or claims against government agencies, where different rules may apply.

How Does Insurance Factor Into Comparative Fault Claims?

Insurance companies conduct their own investigations to assign fault percentages, which do not always align with what a court might decide. Insurers may attempt to shift a larger share of blame onto the injured party because doing so reduces or eliminates the amount they must pay. Documenting the accident thoroughly and gathering strong evidence can counter efforts to inflate a claimant’s percentage of fault.

What Should I Do After an Accident to Protect My Claim?

Gathering evidence as soon as possible after an accident strengthens a party’s position in a comparative fault dispute. This includes taking photos, collecting witness contact information, filing a police report, and seeking prompt medical attention. Insurers can argue that delays in documentation or medical care mean that the injuries were less serious or that the injured party’s own actions contributed to them.

Our Skilled Indiana Car Accident Lawyers at Wilson & Kinsman, LLC, Help Clients Clarify Liability

If you need more information about Indiana’s modified comparative fault rules, contact our Indiana car accident lawyers at Wilson & Kinsman, LLC. Call 574-522-1900, book online now, or submit a form for your free consultation. With office locations in Elkhart and South Bend, Indiana, we proudly serve clients in the surrounding areas.

Give us a call!

574-522-1900

Testimonials

Read what our former clients have to say:

Went out of their way to help me with my case

Tom Wilson and his team went out of their way to help me with my case. I had different attorneys throughout the 4.5 years, Tom and the team picked up and finished my case at awesome time. Thank you Tom and your team are very awesome!!!!!

L.S.

5 stars from start to finish

5 Stars from start to finish – Tom is real and knew exactly what to do to navigate through the obstacles and achieve the best outcome in my case. He got it done, well-done, but more importantly, time and again, Tom and his team demonstrated that they possessed the empathy, foresight, professionalism, and organizational capability to make the difference I needed as they managed my case to a successful conclusion. The team at Wilson Law were attentive and supportive, the terms were fair and affordable, the relationship was forthcoming and they enabled me to confidently understand and manage my own role in my own case.

M.L.

A man of utmost integrity

Tom is very kind and personable. He is a great attorney to work for and work with. He is a man of the utmost integrity and is forthright in his practice. I would confidently recommend his legal services to any person I cared about.

Kayla Christofeno

Eternally grateful to Eric Kinsman and his staff

Eric Kinsman is a kind, professional, and compassionate lawyer who saved our lives when we were falsely accused. We were terrified, confused, and stunned by the situation and he gave us guidance and help in the most stressful moment in our lives. He knows how to break down the game plan in easy to understand language so you know what is going to happen and you don’t feel disconnected or unsure of what is happening. He is very talented and knowledgeable and knows how to work with the prosecutor and really help his clients through the whole process. You’re not a number in Eric’s office – you’re a person and his staff treats you that way too. I will be eternally grateful to Eric Kinsman and his staff and their kindness and compassion.

L.M.

Incredibly thankful

I would like to first give thanks to Eric Kinsman for all he has done for me. I got a criminal mischief charge and was facing a year in jail, this is because I have a past that didn’t look good on me. The prosecutor was determined to get me jail time which gave me high stress, it’s been a long 6 months. What Eric did behind the scenes was incredible not only did he keep me informed on everything the whole time dealing with this case, he also managed to talk the prosecutor into giving me good behavior for a year. I didn’t think there was a chance in the world to make this happen but with the great knowledge he carries he seen things most would have not in this case. He was determined to keep me out of jail and off papers. I’m incredibly thankful to have chosen him as my attorney in this case.

N.W.

Fought my case relentlessly

This law firm fought my case relentlessly for two years to get the settlement that I was seeking.

C.A.

Honest and professional

I was charged with an OWI in Elkhart County and Eric was my first call. He was very helpful and personable throughout the entire process. I certainly appreciated his honesty and professionalism. Eric is definitely well experienced in handling these matters. Thanks to his help and guidance, we were able to have all of our necessary steps done before going to court that helped to retain driving privileges. The judge even remarked at how well the case had been managed during the hearing. With Eric’s help, I was able to obtain specialized driving privileges very promptly. I am still able to tend to my life’s responsibilities and my work. I would highly recommend Eric to anyone else needing help with OWI/DUI charges.

anonymous

What Is the Modified Comparative Fault System in Indiana?